Thursday, November 5, 2009

Chapter 9 to 20 Personal Reflection

When Winnie goes fishing with Miles, she kills a mosquito but asks Miles to let the trout go free. Why would she do that? Would you have done the same? Explain.

13 comments:

Reinhart K. said...

winnie tells Miles to let the trout go because, Winnie feels sorry for the trout, shes the type of person that dosn't like to see anything die.

JeSsIcA said...

Winnie feels like the misqueto is a pain bu the fish although terrifing is beautiful. yes i would have done the same because i like fish but hate buga

curwin said...

i think winnie killed the fly because they bug you and bother you and they are so small and so easy to kill when the fish is biger and almost more alive and free and would feel really bad if the fish would be killed.

Alyssa said...

i think that she did that because a misquito hurts you but the trout didnt do anything to hurt winnie. i wount of done the same thing though

Katrina Smith said...

She didn't want Miles to kill the trout because she thought the trout was beautiful. i wanted have done the same because i would have wanted fish for breakfast.

jordan.beaudry said...

because if mosquitos lived forever
it would be the worst thing possbel
and a terought is a more of a liveing thing than compered ot a fish.you think about it and exolain why ????????............ect
inf.

miranda said...

I think that winnie told him to put the fish back in the water because even know she killed the mosquito I think that she didn't really think about what she was hitting because it was small but since the fish was big she noticed that she did not want it dead. If it were me I would of killed it but that is just my opinion because I like fish but that is what I would of done.

sheldon said...

When takes the place of mae tuck because she real like mae and they are really good friends

Heather said...

Winnie killed the mosquto because It was trying to bite her and it was just a reflex. But the trout presented no harm to her and was not doing anything.I would have done the same thing.

chad said...

she told miles to let it go because she felt sorry for the fish and wanted miles to put it back and no i would of kept it because fish is good to eat

Renate said...

She kills the mosquito because they are pests and you would not eat them but with a fish you would eat a fish. And she couldn't stand that she would eat the fish that she killed.

Micheala said...

Winnie kills the Mosquito because if they keep living then they'll have babies and they'll have babies and so on,she thinks it will be terrible. Winnie thinks that the Trout is beautiful and doesn't think he should die. I think i would do the same, i like fishing but i make whoever is with me fishing put the fish back, because i would not like to be in the fishes place.

Leona said...

Winnie kills the mosquito because if the mosquito drinks from the spring then there would too many of them plus they would kill everything, but if the fish drank from the spring then there would be alot of fish for everyone to eat. yes i would have killed the mosquito because I hate them. No i wouldn't have let the fish go because i don't want fish to over populate the water because i love to swim and if there are too many fish then people will have to fill all the swimming pools with fish and I'm not going swimming eith fish.